On September 29, 2025, a Closter homeowner applied to the Zoning Board of Adjustment for an in-ground pool, an on-grade patio, a retaining wall and a reconfigured driveway. The hearing was January 21, 2026. The house sits in District No. 2, Residential B, where impervious coverage is capped at 30% of the lot. The plan came in at 34.80%. According to the board's January 21, 2026 minutes, a board subcommittee had asked the applicants before the hearing to "explore reducing proposed impervious coverage via smaller proposed swimming pool, demolition of existing carport/shed, etc." The board approved the application. It still took about four months from filing to hearing.
The board weighed square footage against a coverage cap. The borough has proposed a change to how poolside hardscape is counted.
The rule up for a vote on December 9
Closter introduced Ordinance No. 2026:1404 on October 14, 2026. It amends Chapter 176 of the borough code, the swimming pool chapter. The key new paragraph reads:
"No permit for a private in-ground swimming pool, wading pool, tank or plunge shall be issued by the Zoning Officer unless the plans include a deck, patio or other hardscape area around the pool which measures at least four (4) feet in width (excluding the coping) and is located around the at least 50% of perimeter of the pool. Said hardscape shall be included in the impervious coverage calculation."
The plot plan filed with a pool permit application would also have to show that hardscape and include it in the coverage calculation. According to the borough's notice of introduction, the ordinance passed first reading on October 14. The public hearing and final-passage vote are set for December 9, 2026, at 7:00 p.m. If adopted, it takes effect immediately upon final publication.
Closter's residential coverage caps
Closter's zoning Schedule A sets two residential districts. Residence Area A has a 15,000-square-foot minimum lot, and Residence Area B has a 12,500-square-foot minimum. Both cap total building coverage at 20% and total impervious area at 30%.
Section 200-5 of the code defines an impervious surface as "Any material that prevents absorption of stormwater into the ground."
Where recent pool applications landed
The Zoning Board's May 21, 2025 and January 21, 2026 minutes show what happens when the budget runs out. Recent applications that included pools, all heard against the same 30% cap:
| Application | Board meeting | Project | Impervious proposed | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pool and outdoor kitchen | May 21, 2025 | In-ground pool, spa, outdoor kitchen, landscape wall, patio | 38.90% | Approved |
| Pool and driveway, the opening example | January 21, 2026 | In-ground pool, patio, retaining wall, driveway reconfiguration | 34.80% | Approved |
| Pool, pergola and driveway | January 21, 2026 | In-ground pool, pergola, patio, walkway, driveway reconfiguration | 35.70% | Revised plan approved after an earlier proposal was denied |
All three pool projects asked for more than the cap allowed. All three were approved, but the pergola project was approved only after a redesign, and the opening example was approved after the subcommittee asked the owners to consider a smaller pool or removing a carport and shed.
A variance also has a filing cost. Under Chapter A301 of the Closter code, a non-use variance for a single-family or two-family home carries a $200 application fee. There is also a $1,500 minimum escrow for anticipated legal services on a single-family bulk variance, and a $1,000 engineering escrow that "May be required." Professional fees come on top of that. In the January 2026 case from the opening, an engineer and a professional planner testified for the applicants.
Why the board wanted the patio counted from day one
The idea came from the Zoning Board. As quoted in the Ordinance Committee's March 31, 2026 cover letter, the board's report dated December 18, 2025 recommended "a deck, patio or other hardscape area around of at least 4 feet in width at least two sides of any swimming pool, which shall be included in the impervious coverage calculation." The board's July 15, 2026 minutes describe the requirement as a way to improve safety and to "lessen the likelihood of requests for Board relief and unauthorized construction."
The current text went through several versions:
- December 2025 report: 4 feet of hardscape on at least two sides of the pool.
- February 4, 2026: the Planning Board attorney recommended putting the rule in Chapter 176, the pool chapter, instead of the zoning chapter.
- March 2026 Ordinance Committee draft: 3 feet around the entire perimeter. The committee's reasoning was that coping is usually 12 to 18 inches and space is needed to hook up a pool cover, so 3 feet plus coping would give "at least 4 feet around the pool."
- July 15, 2026: the Zoning Board endorsed a 4-foot minimum on 50% of the perimeter, applied to in-ground pools only. The board said a "two sides" rule fits rectangular pools but not free-form ones.
- October 14, 2026: introduced at 4 feet on at least 50% of the perimeter, for in-ground pools.
When the board endorsed the July draft, one voting member considered it too restrictive. The same minutes cover a separate draft amendment to § 200-5 that would define "building coverage." That draft would have counted decks as building coverage only. The board said decks should count as impervious coverage only.
Quick answers
What does the introduced text say about pools? It adds language to the pool definition stating that a pool "may be in-ground or above ground."
Does the 4 feet include coping? No. The ordinance measures the 4 feet "excluding the coping."
Is this already law? Not yet. Final adoption is scheduled for the December 9, 2026 council meeting at 7:00 p.m., where the public hearing will also be held.
Have pool projects been approved above 30%? The Zoning Board has granted impervious coverage variances for pool projects, with the three applications above approved at 34.80% to 38.90%. Each one went through its own hearing.
This post is general information about a proposed borough ordinance, not legal advice. Anyone planning a pool or pricing a home around one should confirm the lot's numbers with a licensed engineer or land use attorney and with Closter's Zoning Officer.
Get a free home valuation from Joseph Aziz Real Estate.